|
The which vs. that usage dilemma pops up when working with dependent clauses—also known as subordinate clauses—that require one of these two relative pronouns. A dependent clause contains a subject and a predicate but cannot stand alone as a complete, independent sentence.
Which and that are used with essential (also called restrictive) clauses, which contain information necessary to the meaning of the sentence, and non-essential (non-restrictive) clauses, which enhance the meaning of the sentence with additional information but are not necessary.
More specifically, which and that are used with a specific type of dependent clause called a relative clause. In this type of clause, the relative pronouns which or that are substituted for the subject or object in the sentence. Identifying this relationship between which and that and the nouns they describe helps us figure out how to use these two relative pronouns.
Which vs. That: The Rules
The first step is to determine whether your dependent relative clause is essential or non-essential to the meaning of the sentence. Does the information have to be there, or does the sentence make sense without it?
You can use this standard rule of thumb to help make your decision: If the dependent clause is essential (restrictive or defining), use that. If the dependent clause is non-essential (non-restrictive or non-defining), use which.
Another way to check your usage is to imagine a set of parentheses around your which or that clause. If you can remove the information in parentheses and the sentence still makes sense, then you have a non-essential clause and can use which. If you need the information in the parentheses, you have an essential clause that requires that.
|
Examples
Essential: Dogs that perform tricks receive treats.
In this sentence, "that perform tricks" is necessary to define the specific group of dogs that receive treats.
Non-essential: David read the history book, which had a blue cover, for his homework assignment.
In this sentence, "which had a blue cover" provides additional but not necessary information. |
Note that the essential clause "that perform tricks" is not set off with commas, but the non-essential phrase "which had a blue cover" is. This is a standard use of punctuation with essential clauses (no commas) and non-essential clauses (commas).
Which vs. That: Are There Really Rules, or Just Preferences?
A contemporary shift in style has resulted in some exceptions to the rules for which and that usage. A writer may make the stylistic decision to use which instead of that as a restrictive pronoun, for example, simply because which sounds better to the ear. Writers who strive for greater precision, however, will follow the defined usage of that as a restrictive pronoun and which as non-restrictive.
In certain contexts, a writer also may choose to substitute which for that to avoid repetition. For example, a sentence beginning "I read a magazine article that says that…" is correct but clunky. The writer may replace the first that with which ("…article which says that…"), allowing for better sentence flow.
It also is important to keep in mind the multiple functions of that in English. It appears in text so often in so many ways that readers see it and may assume it is an unnecessary or even a "filler" word. But before you strike through that with your metaphorical red pen and replace it with which, first determine whether the information in the dependent clause needs to be there.
|
View and comment on this
article on our website.
|
|
Pop Quiz
Using what you understand about which and that, choose the pronoun that is most precise for each sentence. Then determine whether the sentence should contain commas. If so, place the commas in the correct locations in the sentence.
1. Mary burned her mouth on a slice of pizza [that / which] had extra cheese on it.
2. I'll take a slice of pizza [that / which] will be my lunch.
3. Wyoming [that / which] was granted statehood in 1890 elected the first female governor pursuant to a special election in the United States.
4. Joe is on a roll: He wrote yet another song [that / which] won an award.
5. Our family car [that / which] has a red interior does not get good gas mileage.
|
 |
The Blue Book of Grammar and Punctuation
by Lester Kaufman and Jane Straus |
Revised and Expanded Blue Book of Grammar and Punctuation Coming Next Month
The twelfth edition of The Blue Book of Grammar and Punctuation is set for a May 4, 2021, debut. It has been seven years since the eleventh edition was published. So when the publisher, Jossey-Bass, requested another go-round, the team at GrammarBook.com was elated.
You will find the new, extensively revised and expanded version in keeping with our consistent vision of a direct, concise, unfussy grammar book.
The Blue Book, which started life as a booklet for California state employees, has now sold hundreds of thousands of copies. Over the years, we’ve seen the number of subscribers to our weekly newsletter grow from dozens to scores to hundreds; now, there are over 40,000 of you worldwide.
The new edition continues to stress the difference between rules on the one hand and conventions, customs, and tendencies on the other. We also added previously uncovered material, such as irregular verbs, that have been popular topics in our newsletters and blogs. In addition, the Confusing Words and Homonyms section has been greatly expanded, and we have developed all-new quizzes covering even more topics.
The new Blue Book takes on English in all its often maddening complexity, acknowledging its quirks, gray areas, exceptions, limitations, and contradictions. We realize that people want straight answers, but with English, there sometimes aren’t any, and we would be remiss in saying otherwise.
Pre-order your copy of the new edition of The Blue Book of Grammar and Punctuation—order your copy of the book from Amazon or Barnes & Noble now!
|
Free BONUS Quiz for You!
[[firstname]], because you are a subscriber to the newsletter, you get access to one of the Subscribers-Only Quizzes. Click here to take a Capitalization Quiz and get your scores and explanations instantly!
We will be adding many more quizzes this year to our already substantial list of quizzes. If you have suggestions for topics we have not yet covered, please send us a message at help@grammarbook.com.
|
Hundreds of Additional Quizzes
at Your Fingertips
Subscribe now to receive hundreds of additional English usage quizzes not found anywhere else!
Teachers and Employers
Save hours of valuable time! You may assign quizzes to your students and employees and have their scores tallied, organized, and reported to you! Let GrammarBook.com take the hassle out of teaching English!
"Fun to test my skills."
"The explanations really help ... thanks!"
"I can select the quizzes to assign to my students, and then the results are reported to me automatically!"
99¢
QUIZZES
|
Don't need all the quizzes?
You can now purchase the same quizzes individually for ONLY 99¢ each.
Purchase yours here.
|
If you think you have found an error in a quiz, please email us at help@grammarbook.com
|
 |
The Blue Book of Grammar and Punctuation
by Jane Straus, Lester Kaufman, and Tom Stern |
The Authority on English Grammar! Eleventh Edition Now Available
An indispensable tool for busy professionals, teachers, students, homeschool families, editors, writers, and proofreaders.
Available in print AND as an e-Book! Over 2,000 copies are purchased every month!
To order the book, simply click the link to order the book from the GrammarBook.com website.
|
Wordplay
Pop Quiz Answers
1. Mary burned her mouth on a slice of pizza that had extra cheese on it.
2. I'll take a slice of pizza, which will be my lunch.
3. Wyoming, which was granted statehood in 1890, elected the first female governor pursuant to a special election in the United States.
4. Joe is on a roll: He wrote yet another song that won an award.
5. Our family car, which has a red interior, does not get good gas mileage.
|
 |
English In A Snap:
68 One-Minute English Usage Videos FREE |
Learn all about who and whom, affect and effect, subjects and verbs, adjectives and adverbs, commas, semicolons, quotation marks, and much more by just sitting back and enjoying these easy-to-follow lessons. Tell your colleagues (and boss), children, teachers, and friends. Click here to watch.
|
|
